No Divorce Alimony Without Evidence: Court Ruling
On June 4, 2024, the Piacenza Court issued a significant ruling regarding the entitlement to divorce alimony, stating that a spouse must meet the burden of proof to qualify for such support. This decision underscores the importance of substantiating claims for financial assistance following the dissolution of marriage.
The court determined that a request for divorce alimony should be denied if the requesting spouse cannot provide adequate evidence regarding several key factors. Firstly, the claimant must demonstrate the economic and financial conditions of both spouses at the time of the divorce. This is crucial to establish a clear understanding of each party’s financial situation.
Secondly, the court emphasized the need to ascertain whether any significant financial imbalance was a direct result of decisions made during the marriage. Specifically, it must be shown if one spouse sacrificed professional aspirations or income opportunities to fulfill a supportive role within the family unit. The length of the marriage and the age of the requesting spouse are also vital considerations in this evaluation.
Lastly, the ruling addressed whether the economic imbalance could be remedied by the claimant’s professional recovery, taking into account their age and the available job market opportunities. If it is determined that the imbalance is “irreversible,” the claimant must provide proof that they are unable to overcome this disparity.
This ruling establishes a clear precedent, emphasizing that financial support in divorce cases hinges on the ability to substantiate claims with solid evidence. Spouses seeking alimony must be prepared to present detailed financial information and demonstrate the impact of their choices during the marriage to qualify for any support. The court’s decision aims to ensure that alimony requests are grounded in fairness and reality, ultimately leading to more equitable outcomes in divorce proceedings.
VGS Lawyers is a law firm specialised in Italian Family Law. If you need any assistance please send your enquiry at info@vgslawyers.com