Acceptance of Inheritance by a Minor: What Happens Upon Reaching Adulthood?

When a legal representative accepts an inheritance with the benefit of inventory on behalf of a minor, the minor becomes an heir in every respect. This means renunciation is no longer possible once they reach adulthood. Understanding Italian inheritance law is crucial in such cases, particularly regarding probate in Italy and Italian succession law.

Inheritance Acceptance for Minors

• Minors who inherit must have their legal representative (parent or guardian) accept or renounce the inheritance on their behalf.
• Acceptance must be done with the benefit of inventory to protect the minor’s assets, a key concept in Italian estate planning.
• Upon reaching adulthood, can the heir still renounce the inheritance?

This article examines the implications of inheritance acceptance with the benefit of inventory for minors, particularly in light of a recent ruling by the United Sections of the Court of Cassation.

Supreme Court Ruling on Inheritance for Minors

The United Sections of the Court of Cassation, ruling no. 31310 (December 6, 2024), analyzed a case where an heir, after reaching adulthood, wanted to renounce an inheritance that had been accepted on their behalf while they were still a minor. Such cases often involve complexities related to inheritance in Italy and inheritance tax in Italy.

Key Judgment Findings:

• Renunciation is no longer possible if the inheritance was accepted with the benefit of inventory.
• The minor irrevocably becomes an heir as per the legal representative’s decision.

Understanding the Benefit of Inventory

The benefit of inventory is a legal mechanism that allows an heir to limit their liability to the assets of the estate, ensuring that:

• They are not personally liable for the deceased’s debts.
• They are only responsible for debts up to the value of the inherited property.
• This mechanism plays a crucial role in Italian estate tax considerations.

Process of Inheritance Acceptance for Minors

• Parents or guardians must accept with the benefit of inventory.
• Acceptance requires court authorization from the guardianship judge.
• The minor retains limited liability for inherited debts.
• Upon turning 18, the minor must complete an inventory within a year to maintain limited liability.
• This process also applies when selling inherited property in Italy.

What Happens When the Minor Becomes an Adult?

• The minor cannot renounce the inheritance after reaching adulthood.
• To retain protection against inherited debts, they must complete the inventory within one year.
• If the inventory is not completed, the heir becomes liable for the deceased’s debts beyond the estate’s value.
• This is particularly relevant for US citizens inheriting property in Italy and those inheriting property in Italy under Italian succession law.

Resolution of Legal Conflicts

The ruling resolved an ongoing interpretative conflict regarding whether a minor could renounce an inheritance upon reaching adulthood:

• Previous Rulings (e.g., No. 4561/1988, 25666/2008, 841/2014) suggested that minors could still decide upon turning 18.
• Recent Ruling (No. 8034/1993, 15267/2019, and now 31310/2024) established that minors automatically become heirs once their legal representative accepts on their behalf.

Final Legal Standing

• Acceptance with the benefit of inventory is not a temporary condition.
• Once accepted, the minor’s heir status is irreversible.
• The only option upon reaching adulthood is to complete the inventory to maintain financial protection.
• The implications of donation in Italy should also be considered when planning an inheritance.

This ruling provides clarity and legal certainty on the matter, ensuring that inheritance acceptance in Italy on behalf of minors remains a permanent legal act once they reach adulthood.

VGS Family Lawyers is a law firm that specializes in family law matters such as inheritance, separation and divorce, child custody, and more.

In case you need assistance, please write to: info@vgslawyers.com.